Just Stop Complaining About Christian Nationalism

“So here’s what I think. If you spent the last two decades pushing anti-white “racial reconciliation,” or even staying silent while others in your denomination pushed it, but now you’re complaining about “White Christian Nationalism,” you’re the reason it ended up where it is.”

(Jeff Maples – The Dissenter) Nobody wants to be demonized for their skin color. Believe it or not, not even white people. But for the better part of the last two decades, Evangelicalism has been ensnared in what was colloquially called the “racial reconciliation” movement.

Yet, this movement was nothing more than a smokescreen for anti-white racism designed to guilt white people into believing that their skin color “privileged” them in American society, and that the only appropriate response was to denounce themselves and participate in a lifelong charade of racial penance.

It was sick—and those leading the charge knew what they were doing.

Men like Russell Moore, I truly think, believed that by marching their fellow white followers into this movement, they were securing a place for themselves in the future houses of their “minority” masters.

And then others were just too dumb to notice, and just followed along—JD Greear, Danny Akin, and every other Southern Baptist pastor who preached “white guilt” from their pulpits and seminary lecture halls.

But with persistent effort from people who saw what was going on, we were finally able to break the movement and get people to wake up. More people began openly opposing the woke agenda. And finally, it was over.

But not before the damage was done.

The movement drove people out of the Evangelical church…out of the Southern Baptist Convention…out of the PCA. It drove people to embrace self-protectionist movements that, to some degree, seem the total opposite of the “racial reconciliation” movement.

After years of being judged by their skin color, we now have young men who have embraced a version of Christian Nationalism that appears to border on white supremacy. The movement, in various sects, is highly exclusive of non-whites—at least it appears that way—and seems to be a means of self-preservation at the expense of other ethnicities.

Now, I would not consider myself “Christian Nationalist” in the full sense of how some define it, but I would certainly embrace some of the tenets of it without complaint. Would I prefer a nation friendly primarily to Christianity and Christian values while limiting the expression of false religions?

Yeeeeeesss. I would not complain.

Would I prefer the Ten Commandments be the basis for our national policy?

I would vote for that.

But the movement is beyond that. There are some who have embraced such an extreme form of Christian Nationalism that one does not seem to be able to allow room for even Voddie Baucham, Virgil Walker, or Conrad Mbewe.

I am not going to claim that I fully understand the reasoning or motivation behind what appears to be racial exclusion within this movement, so I am certainly open to fair criticism if I am wrong. However, it appears to boil down to what is believed to be a cultural, intellectual, and even spiritual—to some degree—“contamination” of the “American” “Christian” ideal.

In other words, it seems that by allowing non-whites full participation in the American “Christian Nation,” the only thing that could happen is the continual erosion of “white civilization.”

I don’t agree with that—and again, if I’m misinterpreting things, I am open to criticism.

BUT. How can we blame them? How can we point fingers at men like Joel Webbon, Dale Partridge, and other vocal figureheads in this movement and tell them to pound sand?

They got there for a reason, and the reason is that the Danny Akins, the Al Mohlers, the Matthew Halls, the Russell Moores, and the JD Greears all drove them there. For decades, the pounded into the heads of young men and women that being white was a sin, and that unless they die to their ethnic identity and subjugate themselves to the ethnic identity of non-whites, they would persist in eternal sin.

And that’s what has driven so many to this extreme, self-protectionism.

I’m not defending the exclusion of non-whites—especially the citizens who are here, have contributed to American life and culture—from participation. (Though I do strongly support a completely closed border and a highly limited immigration policy.) But I also can’t say that I blame them for thinking in ways of self-preservation.

I also tend to believe that, while national policy should be informed by our Christian values, it should be separated from the function of the Church. In other words, I don’t believe it is the New Testament Church’s responsibility to implement a theocratic government in America—especially one that largely excludes people based on race.

But I’m also not against a government implemented according to biblical values.

So here’s what I think. If you spent the last two decades pushing anti-white “racial reconciliation,” or even staying silent while others in your denomination pushed it, but now you’re complaining about “White Christian Nationalism,” you’re the reason it ended up where it is.

You swung the pendulum so far to the left, that when it finally let go, it had nowhere to swing but to the opposite extreme.

So you have no business complaining.

But at the same time, to those on the right who want a conservative nation with policy informed by biblical values: if you want it to work, don’t make the same mistake the leftists did. Don’t swing so far that you exclude genuinely good people who we need to bring conservatism back to this nation.

But also don’t let pragmatism kill your convictions.

I love America. I want a conservative nation. I want biblically based national policy. I want to stop abortion, outlaw pornography, and end the LGBTQ movement. I want to end the public school system and put the responsibility of raising children back on the parents. I want to stop social welfare systems and wealth redistribution while putting tax money back into the hands of those who have actually paid it.

I want to close the borders and only allow people into the nation who will uphold our conservative values, assimilate to our culture, and contribute to society. And I want the church to be free to preach the gospel and take it out into the world, protected by our constitution to the exclusion of other false religions.

I want families with stay-at-home moms teaching children while dad is out earning the bacon. And I want that to be seen as normal.

I want all that for our nation and more.

But our identity is not in America, not in our American Dream culture, and not in our skin color—it is in Christ. And that’s why God gave us the Church.

Visit Jeff Maples’s Substack page. View article →

Research: Progressive (Social Justice) ‘Christianity’

CRN has compiled a list of false teachers and several other professing Christians we’ve warned you about over the years. The list also contains those we must keep an eye on plus movements, organizations and “frauds, phonies and money-grubbing religious quacks” to mark and avoid as per Romans 16:17-18

CRN publishes a wide range of views for research and study. Please keep in mind that the content of a post doesn’t necessarily reflect the views of CRN.

Join Marsha West on Facebook and MeWe